I live in a apartment in nyc and I had a leaky shower. I informed my landlord who sent a plumber. The plumber informed me I needed to buy the part to repair the shower. It cost about 65 dollars. I was wondering is the landlord suppose to cover the 65 dollars? Can I withhold it from the rent?

Was the part something that you broke or messed with in any way?

If you broke it, you pay.

If it is normal wear and tear maintenance, the landlord pays.